Get InQueensland in your inbox Subscribe

The stumbling Senators who don't know what to do with their vote


Two Liberal senators who threatened to withhold their vote from the government have partially backflipped, leading to an embarrassing about-face in the Senate.


Print article

Senators Gerard Rennick and Alex Antic have written to the government whip saying they would vote with the coalition on all non-legislative matters in the Senate despite saying they would withhold their votes over vaccine mandates.

Labor senator Kristina Keneally scolded the two senators, saying they either had the courage to stand up for their own convictions or they did not.

“Senator Rennick has been telling everyone up hill and down dale that he is not for turning,” she said.

“What did we see (after the vote)? A somewhat ashen-faced, a somewhat embarrassed, a somewhat dishevelled and dissembling Senator Rennick stand up, unable to articulate why he had not voted or what his position was.”

Keneally also lambasted Antic for capitulating to the government, saying their threats were being watered down by the day.

“There he was, Chamberlain with his email, capitulating to the Liberal-National whips.

“(Their protest) is becoming a little more conditional. Either these senators have the courage of their convictions or they do not.”

The government announced it would lower the threshold for people claiming compensation for adverse vaccine effects reduced from $5000 incurred to $1000 after a push from the senator was said to be in exchange for his partial support.

But the government poured cold water on reports of any quid pro quo with Rennick, saying it had been considering the policy change for a number of weeks.

The measure had apparently already gone to cabinet’s expenditure review committee before the recalcitrant senator promised his support on procedural matters.

It followed a stumble by Rennick on Tuesday, which meant the Labor and Greens were able to suspend an inquiry into the ABC and SBS.

Rennick then tried to have the vote taken again hours later after the government admitted he had made a mistake.

Due to the pandemic, the government and opposition have a pairing arrangement when not all senators can attend parliament to ensure votes are accurately recorded.

Rennick was paired with a Labor senator, meaning he was supposed to have voted in line with the government opposing the inquiry’s suspension, but did not show up to the vote.

The inquiry’s suspension passed by a single vote.

A senator can seek to have the vote recommitted if they voted the wrong way or were unable to make it to the chamber before the doors were locked.

Greens senator Nick McKim said recommittals were only for genuine confusion and extenuating circumstances.

“They are not a second shot in golf because you shanked the first one,” he told the Senate.

The government did not seek to recommit the vote on Wednesday morning after Senator tried to do so on Tuesday evening.

More Politics stories

Loading next article