Theresa Dalton, 69, cried in the Queensland Supreme Court after the jury returned its verdict on Monday.
“You’re wrong, you’ve made a mistake,” she repeated.
“How can you do this?”
Dalton, 69, pleaded not guilty to procuring someone to murder her husband of more than two decades in 2010.
It is the second time the former flight attendant has protested her innocence in a Queensland court after a retrial was last year ordered by the Court of Appeal.
Dalton was found guilty in 2019 of arranging a hit on ex-husband Malcolm Stewart in 2010 after their marriage fell apart.
She was sentenced to six years in prison and would have been eligible to apply for parole in August 2021.
The conviction was last year set aside on appeal with Dalton returning to the Supreme Court last Monday.
She maintained her innocence insisting she had never once broken the law.
“I am innocent. I feel this has been a catastrophic miscarriage of justice,” Dalton told the court after the first verdict.
However, after two days of deliberations, the second jury found Dalton guilty on Monday.
In her second trial, Dalton again denied urging boyfriend Anthony Werner to recruit his “old acquaintance” Matthew Neels to kill her husband.
Werner made arrangements to pay $20,000 up-front to Neels with another $20,000 to follow after the hit was executed, crown prosecutor David Finch said.
The “hitman” never carried out the plot, instead pocketing the cash, but the prosecution argued Dalton was still guilty.
Dalton’s “problems” arising out of the separation would dissolve if her former husband was dead, Finch said.
“Paying someone $40,000 to kill Malcolm Stewart was far less expensive than … dividing up their marital assets.”
While Werner put the plan in motion, the trial heard it was Dalton “pulling the strings” by providing the money, the identifying information, and the “urging and encouragement”.
“Theresa Dalton had the motive to want Malcolm Stewart to disappear and the financial means to make it happen, but she needed Mr Werner, in the prosecution case, to help her contact and find someone who could carry it out,” Finch said.
The court heard Neels – an old acquaintance of Werner’s – proved to be a thief, not a killer, taking the $20,000 allegedly provided by Werner when the two met at Burleigh Heads.
“He spent the money and he didn’t follow through with what he was asked to do,” Finch said.Jump to next article