Get InQueensland in your inbox Subscribe

Cairns childcare worker acquitted of manslaughter over toddler's minibus death


A former childcare worker has been acquitted of a charge of manslaughter over the death of a Cairns toddler who was allegedly left behind on a minibus, after a court found she did not have a duty of care to the child.

Print article

Dionne Batrice Grills, 34, was one of two people charged with manslaughter over the death of Malik Nicholas Floyd Namok-Malamoo, 3, who was found dead on a Goodstart Early Learning Centre minibus in February last year.

Police alleged Grills and her co-accused, Michael Glenn Lewis, 45, left the toddler on the minibus after collecting him from his home at Edmonton, south of Cairns.

It is alleged the boy was left on the bus for about six hours on a day when temperatures exceeded 30 degrees Celsius.

Lewis was last year committed to stand trial in the Supreme Court at a date to be set.

A three-day committal hearing for Grills was held at the Cairns Magistrates Court earlier this month to determine whether there was enough evidence to commit her to stand trial.

Magistrate Kevin Priestly said given the sequence of events, a jury could not arrive at a guilty verdict.

“There is a very real possibility, if not probability, that Ms Grills exited the bus leaving the obvious task of transporting Malik to Mr Lewis, while she went on to her new duties,” he told the court.

“There is no evidential basis on which the prosecution might rely to exclude the possibility.

“Finally the statements which have attributed to Mr Lewis and Ms Grills upon first hearing about what happened are entirely consistent with this scenario and sequence of events

“I thereby conclude that the evidence … is not capable of supporting a jury verdict of guilty and I discharge the defendant.”

Grills fought back tears as she addressed the media outside court.

“I am relieved to be cleared of any criminal responsibility for Malik’s death, but I will always carry the heartache of Malik’s death for life,” she said.

“I extend my deepest condolences to Malik’s family for their loss.”

Her defence barrister Tony Kimmins argued Grills had no case to answer as she was not driving the minibus that picked the boy up, and therefore had no legal duty of care.

“Goodstart policy at the time stated it was the driver’s responsibility to check the bus including behind and under all seats before locking and leaving the vehicle when it had been used to transport children,” he told the court earlier this month.

“Further, it is the driver’s responsibility to engage a second educator to check the bus where possible.

“The driver’s responsibility checklist answers the case, with due respect.”

Police prosecutor Megan Howard told the hearing Grills’ employment as a childcare centre worker and her presence on the bus as it picked the toddler up meant she had a duty of care to protect the boy from danger.

“That she was on the bus, in my submission, is enough that she is capable of being committed,” Howard told the court.

“She is culpable and she owed a duty of care — she held that duty and she failed.”

– ABC / Mark Rigby

More News stories

Loading next article